Registered Investment Advisor

Scott Burns' Articles -- Recent and Archived
Print Article Email Article

The Billions Always Start With Pizza.

Some things are inevitable.

Like the word "topless," spelled in neon, in front of a strip joint.

Or "American workers aren't saving enough" on the executive summary of retirement research.

So it is with a new study from EBRI, the Washington, D.C. based Employee Benefit Research Institute. The new study examines retirement income adequacy by age group and household type. It does this by projecting current savings forward. Then, using a complex model, it estimates income and expenses in retirement.

"Can America Afford Tomorrow's Retirees?" tells us that retirees will be short an estimated $45 billion a year by 2030 and $400 billion for the ten years ending in 2030. Those are big numbers. I'll get back to them in a few minutes.

Right now, here are some of their other findings:

•  Single women are more likely to have future financial problems than couples.

•  Younger workers can "avert a personal shortfall" by saving more. Saving an additional 5 percent of income would solve the retirement income problem for many.

•  Older workers, particularly lower income workers with little in savings, probably can't solve their retirement income problem by saving more of their income because it would require more than 25 percent.

•  Personal real estate isn't the answer. Annuitizing the value of your house or selling it to provide additional income does little to solve the retirement income problem.

Reading the study, which is available at www.ebri.org, I couldn't help think I'd like the numbers in nickels and dimes instead of billions. So I called Brooks Hamilton, a Dallas benefits attorney who has devoted years to making 401(k) plans effective vehicles for employee retirement.

Hamilton explained that it was pretty easy to figure out where someone was heading from 401(k) plan contributions. By taking the percentage of income saved, age, current account balance, investment choices, and income you could project forward using historical investment returns. "Basically, you need about 16 years of final pay (in savings) to retire.   Social Security is good for 6 or 7 years of that, so your actual target is around 10 years of final pay, " he said.

When he did that, sometimes with plans that had as many as 7,000 employees, patterns began to emerge. If he sorted employees by their projected accumulation, they fell into three groups. He called them "overs", "fixables", and "brokens."

We don't have to worry about the "overs."

"Those are the people, 10 or 15 percent of employees, who are going to have 15 or 20 years of final income. They'll have more than what is required.

"The largest group of people won't be over. They're saving 2 or 3 percent of their pay. They just won't have enough if they continue that way. But they're fixable."

I asked him to explain.

"If they save more, or work longer, or both, almost everybody can be fixed. I experimented and came up with my '3 by 3' rule. If you increase the percentage of pay being saved by 3 percent and work three more years, until age 68, most workers can retire in dignity.

"If you assume a 9 percent return and typical savings rates, only about one worker in twenty will be OK for retirement. Most aren't saving enough. But when the company puts in an automatic upward adjustment to savings (Something Hamilton urges his corporate clients to do) the figure goes from one in twenty to one in four. That's a dramatic improvement.

"And if they work to age 68, the ratio goes to one in two."

That isn't everyone, of course. There are some employees who are "broken." Because of their age, there is no way their savings rate or remaining years of work can be increased enough to provide an adequate retirement. Mr. Hamilton's goal with corporate clients is to reduce the percentage of "broken" employees. He wants to make the plans work so that 70 to 80 percent of all employees will be able to retire in dignity.

"It's a matter of corporate will. It's a matter of knowing it can be done. We're not talking about a lot of money. For the average employee, it might be as little as the price of a pizza, once a week," Hamilton said.

"Of course it helps when the employer contributes a pizza too," he added.

Next time you hear someone talking in billions, remember this: before it becomes billions, it's pizza.

Saving Retirement a Nickel at a Time

Only published comments... Feb 15 2004, 03:06 PM by scottb


Comments

No Comments

About scottb

Scott Burns has covered the changing world of personal finance and investments for nearly 40 years. Today, he ranks as one of the five most widely read personal finance writers in the country. Scott began his career as a newspaper columnist at the Boston Herald in 1977 where he was also the financial editor. Nationally syndicated in 1981 and now distributed by Universal Press, the column appears in newspapers from Boston to Seattle. In 1985 he joined the staff of the Dallas Morning News where his column quickly became one of the most widely read features in the paper. He left the Dallas Morning News in 2006 to become one of the founders of AssetBuilder and its Chief Investment Strategist. Burns is a graduate of Massachusetts Institute of Technology (1962). He has written four books, including "The Coming Generational Storm" (MIT Press, 2004) coauthored with economist Laurence J. Kotlikoff. His fourth book, also coauthored with Kotlikoff, was published in 2008 by Simon & Schuster. The paperback edition will be available in January, 2010.  "Spend Til' the End" uses consumption smoothing to demonstrate the errors of conventional financial planning. His business experience includes working as a staffer for a major consulting company and service as a director and audit chairman of a NASDAQ listed manufacturing company. He and his wife now live in Dripping Springs, a "hill country" town about 25 miles outside of Austin.


Contact Us

Open Monday-Friday
9 a.m. - 5 p.m. (CST)

ph. 972.535.4040
fx. 214.556.3848
Email Us

1255 W. 15th Street Suite 240 Plano, Texas 75075