AssetBuilder Inc, - Registered Invesment Advisor - Simple Investing Smart Future
in

Registered Investment Advisor

Scott Burns' Articles -- Recent and Archived

Slider-Land

By Scott Burns

FORT MEYERS, Fla.--- Here, people don't ask whether we are headed for a recession. They know a recession is here. For those who live here, the questions narrow down to two.

How much worse will it get?

How long will it last?

For residents, virtually everything hangs in the balance. And I mean everything.

A doctor friend once told me of an eerie feeling that came along with medical practice. Tending a dying patient, he would look out the hospital room window for a moment. Outside, life went on without a pause. The automobile traffic never stopped. People were still in a hurry.

I feel the same way as I drive down Route 41, the highway that connects Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Bonita Springs, and Naples. The roads are still busy. The cars are still shiny. Massive new shopping centers greet the snow birds, the early retirees setting up house, and the usual vacationers escaping the cold of Minnesota, Michigan, Massachusetts and Maine.

At the sales and information office for the Colony Golf and Bay Club in Bonita Springs I meet Robert Burdett. I ask the former photo-journalist if he'll bring me up to date on what has happened since I visited in 2004. He tells me all the condos at La Scala, a very upscale tower I had visited and admired then, were sold.

But everything seemed to stop last summer, he adds. At the Florencia, the newest luxury tower, few purchases were completed when the project was finished last fall. Only a handful of units were sold in the last quarter.

But on Jan. 8, WCI Communities, the embattled developer, lowered prices dramatically. A spectacular penthouse unit that was priced at $1.7 million on Jan. 1 can now be had for $1.3 million, a 24 percent drop. Discounts on other units range up to 40 percent as WCI struggles to survive.

Now, buyers have appeared and units are under contract.

That this can happen to WCI is striking. WCI is a primo developer, a company that understands how to create the experience that upscale buyers seek. The company takes its slogan, “Every element for the perfect life,” very seriously. If this can happen to WCI, it's terrifying to imagine what can happen to the average developer--- or anyone who needs to sell his house.

According to Fort Myers MLS Board figures, it would take 44.5 months--- nearly four years--- to work off the current inventory of homes for sale. That doesn't count the discouraged sellers who have taken their houses off the market but still want to sell. Foreclosures numbered 1,441 in December and 7,324 for the year--- about 4 percent of the single-family homes in Lee County. And most of those foreclosures were after August. The situation is not getting better. Hank Fishkind, an Orlando-based economist, estimates that it may take 4 years for the housing market to recover.

The local News-Press regularly advertises auctions of homes built to sell for $250,000. The minimum bid: $50,000. Small condos are offered with opening bids of $25,000.

Over lunch, another Realtor says those $250,000 houses are now selling for $100,000--- when they sell at all. She also explains that most of the properties that are selling are “short” sales, where the debt and closing costs exceed the sale value of the house.  

The Realtor herself fears becoming a victim. She is spirited, hardworking, and resilient. But the blunt reality is that she is “upside-down.”  She owes more on her house than it would sell for. Worse, she depends on scarce real estate sales for the income to service the mortgage.

Sadly, she is in the same position as the Texas “condo slaves” of the late 1980s.  When new buyers take over distressed houses and condos on the Florida Gulf Coast, they will be able to do what buyers did in the Texas bust---rent the property for less than the Realtor pays on her mortgage. Her long-term financial health may be better if she declares personal bankruptcy than if she toughs it out.

Some of the bust effects are more subtle. The couple I am visiting, friends in their early 80s who refer to themselves as MOOs (Married Only Once) after 57 years of marriage, take me to a dinner party at Eagles Nest, a large and luxurious continuing-care community with a golf course, tennis courts and marina at Shell Point. At 67, I am nearly 20 years younger than the other guests.

After years of long waiting lists, the resident guests tell me, Eagles Nest now has a small number of vacant units. People who want to move there can't because they need to sell their house or condo first. As a consequence, some elderly people who need the support of a continuing-care community are now at risk, trapped in homes they can't sell.

However universal the decline, this isn't bad news for everyone. It means a half-empty glass for sellers. But it may also mean a half-full glass for buyers. For about $800,000, for instance, it is possible to buy a large and essentially new house with a pool in a gated community with deeded boat dockage and direct access to the Caloosahatchee River and the Gulf of Mexico. That's about $275 a square foot. In another gated development, a three-bedroom home with a courtyard pool, boat dockage, and lovely canal views is available for less than $400,000---about $185 a square foot.

According to www.realtor.com there are more than 12,000 listings in Fort Myers alone, with nearly 2,000 available at $125,000 to $175,000. Many cost less than $100 a square foot.

Will prices go yet lower?

No one knows. What's clear, however, is that a sellers' disaster may be a buyers' opportunity. A Florida retirement may now represent an opportunity to exchange a high-priced home elsewhere for a bargain-priced home in sunny Florida.

Sidebar: An Opportunity Check-list

Here is a precautionary list for bargain hunters, culled from conversations with my host, a former executive for a major international company and former commodore of an area yacht club. He has been retired in Florida for more than 20 years.

  • A bargain is about more than price. If the property is an ugly dog, it doesn't matter how low the price is, don't buy it. Remember, many of these houses and condos were built by brainless builders funded by nitwit lenders.
  • Avoid developments that are not yet complete. You don't know how, when, or if the project will be finished. Equally important, you don't know what the long-term homeowner association costs will be because they may be subsidized by the developer.
  • Read the homeowners' association bylaws carefully. Make sure you understand the restrictions and how they will impact your property. Some will protect you. Others may make it difficult to sell the property in the future. Pay particular attention to the association reserves. If the financial reserves are small, you could be walking into a major future assessment.
  • Remember, Florida is hurricane territory. If your development has canals, docks and other water features, there can be significant assessments for repairs. Don't buy if you don't have the money to cope with special assessments.
  • Check the water sources for your community. The long-term drought has reduced the water level in many canals by as much as 3 feet. It has also led to strict rationing of irrigation. Some communities have deep wells for irrigation. Others have shallow individual wells that may run dry.
  • If boating is your aim, check the depth of the canal or other access to open water. Similarly, if living on a golf course is your goal, don't assume it will be there forever. Check the finances and membership of the club.
  • Check the health care services in the area, particularly if you have special needs or a rare malady.
  • If you won't be living there full time, make certain the homeowners' association is responsible for all exterior yard work. That determines, in large measure, the appearance of your development and how you experience it.
  • Don't buy a property planning on future rental income. With thousands of rental properties competing for the same renters, you'll likely be playing a game of rental musical chairs.
  • Do buy a house or condo if you have a solid personal use for it such as retirement, partial retirement, or family vacation home.
  • If you won't be living there full time, make certain you explore the ease and cost of air transportation and car rentals. Include a budget for same in your planning.
  • Don't fool yourself that this market will turn around in a hurry. Whatever the crush of boomer retirees, it will take years to work off the accumulated inventory.  

 

On the web:

March 23, 2004: La Dolce Vita in Naples Florida:

October 22, 2007: Déjà vu', Texas

Published Jan 25 2008, 03:00 PM by admin
Filed under:

Comments

 

ixl333 said:

Scott,

I'm a little disappointed by your use of the word "recession".  You should know better.  A recession is not a slowdown in the economy or a subjective bad feeling that people have, it has a very specific economic definition: 2 consecutive quarters of negative growth.  

January 26, 2008 2:42 PM
 

scottb said:

You weren't there. I was. While I was in Fort Myers the unemployment rate hit 5.7 percent, more than double the rate from a year earlier. Businesses are closing and people, like those who want to enter a continuing care community but can't until they sell their house, are limited in what they can do. I think the later revised economic data will say the area was in a recession, probably starting in the fourth quarter. Remember, the definition of a recession is two quarters of actual decline and the data is often revised afterwards so the careful definition of a recession is never seen until we are well into it or coming out of it. Scott
January 28, 2008 6:35 PM
 

Scott Burns and recession in Ft Meyers - Early Retirement Forums said:

Pingback from  Scott Burns and recession in Ft Meyers - Early Retirement Forums

January 29, 2008 9:44 PM
 

ABModerator02 said:

I just want to congratulate you on noticing what I believe non of these canditates have noticed or even the fed for that matter.  Recession is not only a tangible item measured by the GDP, but it's an experience, that I believe you feel way before it can be measured.  

We are in a great recession down here in Florida.  Believe me, it's not only limited to housing, but it has already spilled into all other avenues of business in South Florida.  I was in banking for roughly 7 years and in Real Estate for over 10, and the recession is starting to take over the commercial market as well. Local Commercial banks are finding it harder and harder to facilitate lending for Commercial Projects, developers who were involved in Both Residential and Commercial are now lacking liquidity to have their projects meet the bank's revised Loan to Value Limits, Bank boards are not approving loans and requiring as much as 50% loan to value on projects.  

Small business are feeling the affects as well.  Small automotive shops are suffering, gyms are loosing members, coffee shops are empty, restaurants are not as packed on Friday evenings.  The affects are definately here.

Tommy

January 31, 2008 9:45 AM
 

Registered Investment Advisor said:

By Scott Burns A recent listing of mortgage foreclosure rates in 100 top areas drew a lot of attention

February 22, 2008 3:22 PM
 

worriedinTX said:

My daughter married a young man is a road warrior as they say. He  does project management and flies to lengthy out-of-state-projects Sunday, coming home Fridays.

He bought a small 1bd/1bath condo south of Sarasota, FL in 2003--before they were dating seriously. He had been living/flying out of Atlanta and hared Hartsfield with a passion--hated the winter weather and traffic.  For his job, all he needed was an airport w/in an hour's drive, so he sold his Atlanta condo and bought one half-a-block from the Gulf in an over 55 condo community.  To him, it wsa the perfect vacation home because that is what he considered his weekends there--vacations.

Once they decided to marry in 05 however, hindsight shows he should have put it on the market. But the access to the beach and general belief in its long-term maketability made him resistant to selling.  Back then  he could have covered his mortgage w/o a problem--probably even made a profit because the market inhis area still had upside...

Now they have been married several years and want to start a family--which is impossible where they are living. Their area is awash in condos--small and large, cheap and expensive.

TOTAL buyers' market even for SFR--it is almost to the point that they are thinking they could keep the condo--turn it into a rental unit-- and buy a second home to live in if they found the right deal.

He is doing well with his job in efficiency/lean mfg project management--which should do well considering the downturn in the economy. He has possibility of strong promotion within a year and she is working as well.

My husband has even broached the idea that we should buy their condo as vacation-investment property to use when we visit or maybe half-interest in it---to help them get some equity to invest in SFR. We could afford to buy the condo for cash, maybe even set it up as some sort of REIT investment out of his self-employment penion funds. But that would not be a smart move to me. I think the market is still dropping in Fl--and the condo's nearness to the Gulf/hurrican/insurance situation worries me.

The unit itself would work great as a vacation rental for a couple or even a single person residence but would be difficult to lease long-term for enough to cover mortgage costs probably

.

This is basically their only debt--no college loans to repay and little credit card debt--and yet it is an albatross around their necks. They are like the "condo-slaves" in Dallas  that I remember reading about in your column many years ago.

Any suggestions for possible solutions?

Some people are in bad shape because they were trying to make a mint on the upsurge of the housing bubble  and some people just believed the bubble would never burst and overspent what they could afford--that is not their senario.

I don't feel any sympathy most people who tried to profit from the sub-prime mess and the company execs like Mozillo should go to jail IMO.

My daughter and her husband are just caught in the backlash of their greed.

March 17, 2008 8:47 AM
 

scottb said:

Tommy, Thanks. ixL333 wasn't the only reader who questioned my using the "R" word in that column. I think we are discussing hard data only we need to be very precise in our language. But that was a "boots on the ground" column, not a statistical column. Scott
March 17, 2008 2:45 PM
 

Registered Investment Advisor said:

By Scott Burns and Laurence J. Kotlikoff "... let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we

March 28, 2008 3:14 PM
Copyright © 2007 - 2008, AssetBuilder Inc - DFA Advisor. All Rights Reserved.