AssetBuilder Inc, - Registered Invesment Advisor - Simple Investing Smart Future
in

Best option for an emergency fund?

Last post 07-16-2008 1:43 PM by scottb. 1 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (2 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-10-2008 7:28 AM

    Best option for an emergency fund?

    Hi -- I am currently investing in AB14, but I have about $50K that I keep in an emergency fund.  The amount is relatively high because I own my own business and who knows -- I may need to pay in capital at some point.

     Right now the emergency fund resides in the Vanguard CA money market and Vanguard short term bond index fund.  I've read Spend til the End and Coming Generational Storm and am curious about TIPS.  Do you recommend TIPS for a portion of an emergency fund?  And if so, would investing in the Vanguard TIPS index get me approximately the same return (minus fees) of going with TIPS straight-up through the Treasury?

     Thanks

    Drew

  • 07-16-2008 1:43 PM In reply to

    Re: Best option for an emergency fund?

    Drew,

    I don't think TIPS are a good investment for an emergency fund for two reasons.

    First, part of the return you get from TIPS is "phantom income"--- its the increase in value of the security you get from the CPI adjustment and it isn't paid in cash. It is, however, considered taxable income. So you can end up paying taxes using money from other sources. That hardly fits an emergency fund. It's also why most advisors suggest that TIPS be held in tax-deferred accounts.

    Second, when you invest in short term TIPS there is virtually no premium over the CPI adjustment. That may still get you a good return relative to regular Treasury bills, but it aggravates the phantom income tax issue. You only get a substantial (nearly 200 basis points) premium over the CPI by investing long term. You don't want to do that with emergency fund dollars.

    With $50,000, however, you can do nicely by holding a short term Treasury ETF such as BIL (SPDR 1-3 month Treasury bill). It currently yields 3.3 percent. While you will have to pay a commission to buy shares and another to sell, discount commissions of $10 make that reasonable for larger sums. With an expense ratio of only 0.14 percent, it has very low costs compared to most broker platform money market accounts.

     Here's the link to BIL on Yahoo: http://finance.yahoo.com/q?s=bil

    Scott 

Page 1 of 1 (2 items)
Copyright © 2007 - 2008, AssetBuilder Inc - DFA Advisor. All Rights Reserved.