What Investors Can Learn From Crazy and Not-So-Crazy Brits
March 25, 2021

What Investors Can Learn From Crazy and Not-So-Crazy Brits

The British have long had a reputation for betting on almost anything. But that doesn’t make them crazy. When the odds are low, the rewards are high. And when the odds are high, the rewards are low. It’s common to see big bets on whether aliens exist, who will win an Oscar (and whether they’ll cry during the acceptance speech). Several bets have been placed on which year the world will end. Good luck collecting on that one.

To be fair, betting is prolific in every country. And when veteran bettors place wagers, they typically know the odds. If you place a bet, for example (as some Brits have!) that your child will star for Manchester United, the bookies will want to know everything about you and your kid. That helps bookies define the odds and it helps bettors make more informed decisions.

Investors in actively managed funds could learn a lot from this. After all, few of them know their odds of beating the market or how much they could win.

According to the SPIVA Scorecard, the long-term odds of buying an actively managed fund that will beat its benchmark index are low. As such, the payoff should be huge. But that’s not the case.

Imagine this scenario:

A Manchester United soccer player carries his 1-year-old son into a British betting house. The bookie acquires all kinds of information about the father and his mother. Assume he then determines the boy’s odds of success are 1 in 7. You figure this might be your chance to win really big. Under normal circumstances, betting on a seven-to-one underdog would see you winning seven times your money if the bet panned out. 

But what if the bookie said this?

“If you bet $1,000, and the kid makes it, you’ll earn about a $20 profit. And if the kid doesn’t make it, you’ll lose $50.”

If that happened, you wouldn’t likely pull a muscle reaching for your credit card.

Investors in a diversified portfolio of actively managed funds won’t likely post an overall loss over a period of ten years or longer. But that Manchester United bet still has plenty in common with these products. For example, based on SPIVA’s research, the odds of picking an actively managed fund that will beat a broad U.S. stock market index are about 1 in 7, too. That’s based on the fact that about 86 percent of actively managed U.S. funds trailed the U.S. market over the 20 years ending December 31, 2020. As shown below, actively managed funds in 18 categories posted similarly poor results over 20-year periods.

Table of Percentage of US Equity Funds Underperforming their benchmark

If you invested with actively managed funds, you would be saddling your money with a 7:1 underdog. And if your gamble paid off, you should expect to beat the market by about 0.97 percent per year. However, if you invest with index funds (a 7:1 favorite) you should expect to beat the typical actively managed fund by about 2.01 percent per year. That’s according to Alex Benke, based on research he conducted between 1997 and 2012.

Table of Percentage of US Equity Funds Underperforming their benchmark

Few veteran punters would wager on that bet… if they knew the odds. Even fewer would take that gamble if they saw research from the SPIVA Persistence Scorecard: top-performing actively managed funds during one measured time period usually underperform the next. That’s why, choosing to buy actively managed funds over index funds is one of the silliest bets you could make, after betting on the date that the world will end, of course.

Related Articles

This article contains the opinions of the author but not necessarily the opinions of AssetBuilder Inc. The opinion of the author is subject to change without notice. All materials presented are compiled from sources believed to be reliable and current, but accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This article is distributed for educational purposes, and it is not to be construed as an offer, solicitation, recommendation, or endorsement of any particular security, product, or service.

Performance data shown represents past performance. Past performance is no guarantee of future results and current performance may be higher or lower than the performance shown.

AssetBuilder Inc. is an investment advisor registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Consider the investment objectives, risks, and expenses carefully before investing.